"Hi
My sleep clinic discharged me, saying they were happy I was self-managing. Roll on a decade and the cardiologists taking care of me were very unimpressed and I was re-enrolled. I expect remote monitoring with current generation Resmed…"
Sleep Apnoea Forum Bringing Help + Support to the Patient
Sleep Apnoea sufferer refused gastric band operation
An OSA sufferer from Stoke on Trent is taking his case to court after his local health authority refused him Gastric Band surgery, because he's not obese enough.
You can see his story here:http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-14084455
We know that OSA , left untreated, gives rise to other disorders. This poor man has severe Type 2 diabetes weighs 22 stones and has a BMI of 42; he's 62. As a diabetic, presumably he is on a strict diet, but that is not going to be enough. I don't know if he is taking his diabetes medication regularly (Metformin) to try to keep his blood-sugar in check, he doesn't say. He certainly needs to lose weight.
But the irony of the situation is that, with a BMI of 42, he is not big enough to justify Gastric Band surgery: no-one with a BMI of less than 50 qualifies, according to the PCT in North Staffordshire.
What is your opinion? Do you think the PCT should think again, or has this man neglected his health for many years and now puts the blame on the health service for refusing him the treatment he needs?
Is it the same scenario as the guy with bronchitis who smokes 20 a day? Does the health authority have the right to refuse treatment where there is evidence of abuse?
Views: 516
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Kath Hope on
-
Excellent points Rosemary. You also have the right to keep on boasting after doing so incredibly well with all that weight loss, along with Suzie on here - Well Done girls :)
Rosemary Kemp said:
Too right! Not only will he have an incredibly restricted diet but he will have a lot of pain for a while. It doesn't necessarily lead to the sleep apnoea disappearing either. I have lost over six stone now (as I keep on boasting about - such a show off) but I still have obstructive, central and mixed apnoeas. I may eventually be cured but it isn't very likely. Much better though. No question about that.
All surgery carries risk as well. If it saves the man's life and saves him and the tax payer from even more interventions to keep him well, then the damage limitation of the operation is worthy. I am just so relieved that I didn't have to go through yet more surgery. Being cut and operated on is no fun. Fast weight loss can also lead to bags of skin and infections under the skin so if you can do it any other way, I am sure that it is a good idea to try!!
Rosemary
- ‹ Previous
- 1
- 2
- Next ›
About
Sleep Apnoea Forum
New to the Sleep Apnoea Forum?
1. Stop by our Sleep Apnoea Welcome Center to introduce yourself to the SleepGuide community.
2. Start a New Topic of Conversation.
3. Post your photos - of yourself, your old CPAP machine, your new CPAP machine, your pet, something about you!
Interested in advertising, have a problem or need to contact us? Click the Report an Issue page.
Latest Activity
"Hi Jonathan,
Thanks again for the info. My cpap *should* be monitored by the NHS though I haven’t had any contact from them since pre-covid. I checked out the link you gave to access extra data and I think that’s going to be…"
"Hi
I have the ResMed Airsense 10 Autoset (APAP). It's monitored remotely by my NHS sleep clinic and I believe they can make changes to the settings. I don't know whether they are notified if I make changes, nor whether they…"
"Hi Jonathan,
Thanks for the reply. I'd say that I'm fairly technical. I have the ResMed Airsense 10 Elite machine. I've discovered that I can upload data wirelessly from my machine and having lowered the pressure by…"
"Hi
You don't say how technical you are, or what sort of machine you use. However https://www.sleephq.com/ has software which allows you to upload data from compatible machines, and analyse your sleep "score", including a…"
air bubbles after weight loss
Hi,I've been on Mounjaro for about 3 months now, not primarily for weight loss, but I have lost weight around my face and neck. I've noticed that I am increasingly getting air bubbles in my mouth which of course is disturbing my sleep (and my…See More
Micro plastics risks
I was reading an article in the I newspaper today written by a journalist who had her blood tested for micro plastics and was shocked by the results.…See More
job with the charity
Was wondering if there might be a job for me with Hope2Sleep?(I also just asked this of a group by mistake)See More
For Sale - Ventura Full Total Face CPAP Mask
I’m selling an Ventura Full Total Face CPAP Mask Large and two spare liners. I bought it new from the Hope2Sleep shop, but it is not suitable for me. Only used for about two weeks so I have washed it thoroughly. Because of this, it is very much…See More
"I put in a claim for PIP which was denied and now I am over 66 and on pension I tried for AA. Denied again.I have other health conditions ( Diverticular disease and Bile Acid Malabsorbtion ) which I consider hard to live with and they refused all of…"
"No personal experience, but CPAP.com review of AirMini
The AirMini runs at about 30 decibels, which is about the same sound level as a whispered conversation. For comparison, full-sized CPAPs tend to run around 26-28 decibels. Due to their…"
ResMed AirMini for travel
I am considering either buying or renting an AirMini for a forthcoming holiday this month where I will be sharing a twin room. I have read that they’re quite noisy and I don’t want to waste my money on either rental or purchase if the noise level…See More
"Hi, I use a ResMed F20 and had the same issue with the silicone full face mask causing red marks and soreness on my nose bridge. I switched over to the Airtouch memory foam full face masks which are expensive and not supplied by the NHS, but the…"
"It's very much still relevant and we're getting closer to have them manufactured and has been no easy challenge. In fact we were speaking with the company working with us on this only yesterday. If you're not on our newsletter list…"
"I expect others may have responded by now, but I use the Fitlife full face mask. I kept getting a hard lump on my nose when first starting out & it got so bad that I ended up buying my own masks as my clinic would only give the Fitlife to new…"
© 2025 Created by The SleepGuide Crew.
Powered by
