Hope2SleepGuide

Sleep Apnoea Forum Bringing Help + Support to the Patient

I recently had a sleep trial with a Mandibular Device made personally and privately for me by my dentist.  All the research I have found has been positive for mandibular device use in sleep apnoea.  To give the clinic something to compare with I used the Device for six hours with the trial and then continued on with my CPAP respironics machine for another five hours still on the trial.

Disappointingly The Mandibular Device had absolutely no effect on my sleep apnoeas, whereas CPAP absolutely cured them. 

My question is 'has anyone who is an APAP/CPAP user been successful with a Mandibular Device???'

Views: 146

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

That's very interesting June, and pleased to hear you were able to test the Mandibular with the help of the clinic.  I hear of so many people who decide to use these instead of CPAP, find their snoring diminishes and assume the apnoeas have been dealt with too, which is not often the case.

The mandibulars are only recommended for mild sleep apnoea, but I would have been intrigued to find out if they further improved peoples' AHI when used at the same time as CPAP.  It may be that the reasons you have OSA are not connected to your jaw, so in your case it wouldn't help.  I would still like to trial one myself one day, and like you, would love to hear of any others who have proven success with them.

June Ann, I can't answer your question because I have never tried one, my thoughts are if APAP/CPAP works, why change and in my case CPAP works for me.

Hi Terry, 

My main hope for wanting the Mandibular Device to be successful was for convenience.   It would pop into my handbag and be convenient for freedom.   In my case also my CPAP works excellent for me but of course it takes planning to take it with you.  It was worth trying though.
 
Terry Vella said:

June Ann, I can't answer your question because I have never tried one, my thoughts are if APAP/CPAP works, why change and in my case CPAP works for me.

Yes, I understand why you tried June, as even if the results weren't quite as good as CPAP, it would have come in handy at times like travelling on planes etc.

June Ann Rymer said:

Hi Terry, 

My main hope for wanting the Mandibular Device to be successful was for convenience.   It would pop into my handbag and be convenient for freedom.   In my case also my CPAP works excellent for me but of course it takes planning to take it with you.  It was worth trying though.
 

Mandibular advancement devices can work for patients, but the side effects are horrible and need to be disclosed by any dentist who makes a device like this.  Side effects include permanent tooth movement and jaw growth!  My husband's mouth was destroyed by a TAP device he used for several years because he didn't want to try CPAP.  When I was diagnosed and excitedly tried the AUTO CPAP, I had immediate results the first two days that amazed me.  I felt younger, more alive and had more energy than ever in my life!  My husband watched me sleep quietly with the mask/CPAP and finally decided to try it himself - sheesh, if I could do it, then what the heck was he wasting his time with a jaw-jacker for?  He adapted to it quickly and now we have dualing CPAP machines on either side of the bed.  He didn't realize how much the MAD had affected his dentition until he stopped using it.  His jaw is permanently jacked out several millimeters and his teeth no longer have occlusion.  He no longer makes these type of devices due to the severe damage it did to his own mouth.  It is imperitive that patients have full disclosure of side effects!  Feel free to contact me for more info.  I'm in the USA.  Thanks for allowing me to join this forum!  Blissfully sleeping with CPAP :-)  Brenda

Great to have you on-board Brenda, and thanks for this valuable feedback.  My own dentist has sleep apnoea, and he told me how uncomfortable the mandibular devices can be.  Last I heard he was changing to CPAP too, as apart from being uncomfortable, he was convinced his own device wasn't treating his apnoeas anymore.

Does your husband have any advice for the few people who suffer from the loosening of teeth caused by the masks (apart from the obvious of trying to slacken the straps)?  I had this issue once with a previous mask, so I used to alternate between my 2 favourite masks at the time.

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Sleep Apnoea Forum

New to the Sleep Apnoea Forum? 

1. Stop by our Sleep Apnoea Welcome Center to introduce yourself to the SleepGuide community.
2. Start a New Topic of Conversation.
3. Post your photos - of yourself, your old CPAP machine, your new CPAP machine, your pet, something about you!

Interested in advertising, have a problem or need to contact us? Click the Report an Issue page.

 

Latest Activity

Jonathan replied to Iain Noble's discussion Resmed Airfit F20 Woes
"Hi.  No first hand experience, but you can see reviews here, which are mixed: https://www.cpap.com/productpage/resmed-airfit-f40-full-face-cpap-mask I notice cpap.com still appear to be selling the Quattro FX.  I have imported stuff from…"
yesterday
Iain Noble posted a discussion

Resmed Airfit F20 Woes

Dear FolksI have been using the Resmed Quattro FX mask ever since I was diagnosed over 7 years ago.…See More
yesterday
Iain Noble replied to Becky Murkin's discussion F20 AirFit small marking bridge of nose
"Hi All I can say is I feel your pain! I got the F20 as a replacement this year and it is very uncomfortable. I have just ordered the new Resmed F40 which is very small and light and so far it has been a lot easier to use for a mouth breather that…"
yesterday
Sarah Martin is now a member of Hope2SleepGuide
Saturday
jjimjam updated their profile
Apr 17
Kath Hope replied to Becky Murkin's discussion noisy humidifier normal?
"It sounds like you're getting rainout issues (condensation) so here's an article to help with this. www.hope2sleep.co.uk/water-in-the-mask-hose-known-as-rainout"
Apr 16
Becky Murkin posted a discussion

noisy humidifier normal?

Hello,I have an air sense 10 auto.When I have the humidifier and the heated tube plugged in it makes a sort of drumming noise. Like that at the gallows in films.Is this normal? It wakes me up  and I have to give up and switch off  for the night.See More
Apr 16
John posted a discussion

Dentists in Hull that know about Mewing ?

I was wondering if there are any dentists in Hull who know about John & Mike Mew, and changing jaw shape over time?I could add that I saw an ENT consultant recently and she said jaw shape, malocclusion, is genetic, which has become a debatable…See More
Apr 9
Profile IconKaren Mcleod, Fiona Watson, Teresa Hobbs and 5 more joined Hope2SleepGuide
Apr 3
Jonathan replied to John's discussion Airsense 10 -humidifier runs dry
"I did replace the tank in my SleepCube, and had to regularly take the silicone sealing gasket out and give it a goof clean, but not infrequently found it standing in a pool of water in the morning.  The machine sat on a tray because of…"
Mar 26
John posted a discussion

Nasal valve collapse

Does anyone have any experience of nasal valve collapse?Wondering if I have this but I don't know what the norm is.Been trying widgets that hold the nose open and it's like night and day.See More
Mar 24
John replied to John's discussion Airsense 10 -humidifier runs dry
"Wow it's the other way round for me.I found with the Sleepcube I'd often have a good bit of water still there in the morning. Today I woke up with a dry tank on the Resmed again and it's not on full heat or flow. I got it on 6…"
Mar 24
Becky Murkin posted a discussion

F20 AirFit small marking bridge of nose

Please help or give advice all wise people on here.I have had the Resmed F20 AirFit small mask for over a month. Seals yet…See More
Mar 19
Frances Knight replied to Frances Knight's discussion Air Sense 10 - changing pressure settings
"A very helpful reply Jonathan. I found the pressure setting for the full face mask to be too high when I changed to a nasal mask, but perhaps I should have persisted? I'll try again and I'll also discuss with the clinic whether an APAP…"
Mar 13
Jonathan replied to Frances Knight's discussion Air Sense 10 - changing pressure settings
"Ramble alert!  My history is that I spent part of each week at a different location, so bought a second machine identical to my fixed pressure NHS machine and set it up to match using the clinician menu.  This was a very long time…"
Mar 12
Frances Knight replied to Frances Knight's discussion Air Sense 10 - changing pressure settings
"Thanks Jonathan - I had seen the YouTube video. My question is really about the experience of people who have control of their pressure settings, for example those people who have bought their machines directly and not obtained them through an NHS…"
Mar 12
Jonathan replied to Frances Knight's discussion Air Sense 10 - changing pressure settings
"This is NOT a recommendation http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VNUWhd2UgQM"
Mar 11
Frances Knight posted a discussion

Air Sense 10 - changing pressure settings

I have been successfully using my air sense 10 since OSA diagnosis, and my AHI is now under 2. I had an appointment with my clinic this week and have been told there is no need for further appointments and just to contact them if I need supplies or…See More
Mar 11
Swen Greve is now a member of Hope2SleepGuide
Mar 4
Jonathan replied to Sue Reeves's discussion A few questions..
"If you have a helpful GP, I would ask them to re-refer you to the sleep clinic."
Mar 3

© 2024   Created by The SleepGuide Crew.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service