Hope2SleepGuide

Sleep Apnoea Forum Bringing Help + Support to the Patient

Currently, there are a couple of well-known 'Sleep Apnoeacs' in the news.

Ed Milliband resorted to surgery for treatment for his Sleep Apnoea: Big mistake!  The latest reports (from the Beeb) suggest the op. was not a success.  Ed had, and I suppose, still has, a deviated septum, causing his OSA.  There have been a number of cruel aspertions cast in Ed's direction, mostly saying he has had the operation to make his voice sound more assertive and confident. But to submit to surgery, if that is the sole purpose is really a step too far, don't you think?

 

Whatever your political views, Ed Milliband has picked up a poisoned chalice in assuming the Labour Party leadership. Whatever he proposes, he's damned if he does and damned if he doesn't: he finds himself in an impossible position, as the art-mistress said to the gym-instructor. He sets about curing his Sleep Apnoea, and it hasn't worked.

Surgery, in my opinion, should be the very last resort in treating Sleep Apnoea, but I feel sure other members here will disagree with that. It's irreversible, it cannot be undone, which means if it hasn't done the trick, you can't go back to the drawing-board and try again.

And the other Sleep Apnoeac?  None other than Mike Tindall, Captain of the England Rugby Team, now husband of the redoubtable Zara Phillips and son-in-law of the Princess Royal. As if that were not enough, he, too, has a deviated septum, in fact, if his photograph on the cover of this month's Readers Digest is anything to go by, it's more like a doubled-over septum! 

Views: 81

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I just hope that Ed Miliband has a sleep study done once his nose has settled down after the op to see if he still has sleep apnoea, and not just assume the treatment's worked.  Removing the tonsils and adenoids out in children does often cure their sleep apnoea, but it does tend to come back in later life.  Therefore, I doubt that the removal of Ed's adenoids has cured his apnoeas.  Regarding his deviated septum operation, I had the same procedure (plus surgery on my enlarged turbinates) back in April.  No way did I have this as a cure for OSA, but to make my CPAP therapy better and more comfortable - which it has!  I've been a mouth breather all my life through nasal problems so it's wonderful to now be able to breathe through my nose.  Having said that, I still do have to remind myself constantly to breathe through my nose, as mouthbreathing's obviously become a habit, but as this improves I'm hoping to try a nasal mask instead of the full face.

Lots of people go in for operations to try to cure their OSA, but the success rate is not good.  Whilst often it can appear to have cured them initially, the symptoms usually return. 

There are several other operations I could try, and in fact my surgeon wanted to cut away at my large soft palate, but NO WAY would I let him, and nor will I be putting myself through unnecessary painful surgery when CPAP does it's job.  I've spoken to too many people who have had failed surgery, and also who've managed to cure one problem and cause another.  Dr Park's as most of you will know, is a very proficient Ear Nose + Throat Specialist in New York, and even he tries to get his patients on CPAP before turning to surgery.  In fact it was him who advised me not to let my surgeon anywhere near my soft palate unless I was having my jaw re-aligned as well - yikes!

 

I think Ed Miliband is very brave to have this Op to cure his sleep Apnoea as are you Kath.  The main thing I find that it is , at the moment, brought into public discussion from which other sufferers, and people who undiagnosed, get to understand what it is and that there IS help available., even if you dont want to take it. I do know that if you are diagnosed and drive for your living then you have to use a CPAP machine.  That is what I was told anyway.

I would be interested to know what you mean by a sleep study.  I dont know if I had one.  Now I am diagnosed I find I dont have any doctor to discuss problems I am having.  The hospital check my machine but that is basically all that happens.  What are other sufferers experiences?



Kath Hope said:

I just hope that Ed Miliband has a sleep study done once his nose has settled down after the op to see if he still has sleep apnoea, and not just assume the treatment's worked.  Removing the tonsils and adenoids out in children does often cure their sleep apnoea, but it does tend to come back in later life.  Therefore, I doubt that the removal of Ed's adenoids has cured his apnoeas.  Regarding his deviated septum operation, I had the same procedure (plus surgery on my enlarged turbinates) back in April.  No way did I have this as a cure for OSA, but to make my CPAP therapy better and more comfortable - which it has!  I've been a mouth breather all my life through nasal problems so it's wonderful to now be able to breathe through my nose.  Having said that, I still do have to remind myself constantly to breathe through my nose, as mouthbreathing's obviously become a habit, but as this improves I'm hoping to try a nasal mask instead of the full face.

Lots of people go in for operations to try to cure their OSA, but the success rate is not good.  Whilst often it can appear to have cured them initially, the symptoms usually return. 

There are several other operations I could try, and in fact my surgeon wanted to cut away at my large soft palate, but NO WAY would I let him, and nor will I be putting myself through unnecessary painful surgery when CPAP does it's job.  I've spoken to too many people who have had failed surgery, and also who've managed to cure one problem and cause another.  Dr Park's as most of you will know, is a very proficient Ear Nose + Throat Specialist in New York, and even he tries to get his patients on CPAP before turning to surgery.  In fact it was him who advised me not to let my surgeon anywhere near my soft palate unless I was having my jaw re-aligned as well - yikes!

 

A Sleep Study is just another name for the Sleep Test I hope you had when you were first diagnosed.  Some people go into hospital overnight to get wired up and their sleep patterns checked, and some people have a home study where they bring the equipment home and wire themselves up.

In our area, the doctor discharges us to the Sleep Unit and we have a team of nurses/physiologists who then look after us.  They see us once a year to check the machines, but do also want to know how we're getting on.  If there are any problems they can't sort then the refer us back to the doctor who gave us the diagnosis.  The service here is very good, as they want people to contact them if they have any problems before their yearly check-up and will always make an appointment for them.

 

Sally Gould said:

I think Ed Miliband is very brave to have this Op to cure his sleep Apnoea as are you Kath.  The main thing I find that it is , at the moment, brought into public discussion from which other sufferers, and people who undiagnosed, get to understand what it is and that there IS help available., even if you dont want to take it. I do know that if you are diagnosed and drive for your living then you have to use a CPAP machine.  That is what I was told anyway.

I would be interested to know what you mean by a sleep study.  I dont know if I had one.  Now I am diagnosed I find I dont have any doctor to discuss problems I am having.  The hospital check my machine but that is basically all that happens.  What are other sufferers experiences?



I have not seen much success with the operations. Even when they do work most people are not disciplined enough to keep the apnea from returning.

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Sleep Apnoea Forum

New to the Sleep Apnoea Forum? 

1. Stop by our Sleep Apnoea Welcome Center to introduce yourself to the SleepGuide community.
2. Start a New Topic of Conversation.
3. Post your photos - of yourself, your old CPAP machine, your new CPAP machine, your pet, something about you!

Interested in advertising, have a problem or need to contact us? Click the Report an Issue page.

 

Latest Activity

Jonathan replied to John's discussion Airsense 10 -humidifier runs dry
"I did replace the tank in my SleepCube, and had to regularly take the silicone sealing gasket out and give it a goof clean, but not infrequently found it standing in a pool of water in the morning.  The machine sat on a tray because of…"
Tuesday
John posted a discussion

Nasal valve collapse

Does anyone have any experience of nasal valve collapse?Wondering if I have this but I don't know what the norm is.Been trying widgets that hold the nose open and it's like night and day.See More
Sunday
John replied to John's discussion Airsense 10 -humidifier runs dry
"Wow it's the other way round for me.I found with the Sleepcube I'd often have a good bit of water still there in the morning. Today I woke up with a dry tank on the Resmed again and it's not on full heat or flow. I got it on 6…"
Sunday
Becky Murkin posted a discussion

F20 AirFit small marking bridge of nose

Please help or give advice all wise people on here.I have had the Resmed F20 AirFit small mask for over a month. Seals yet…See More
Mar 19
Frances Knight replied to Frances Knight's discussion Air Sense 10 - changing pressure settings
"A very helpful reply Jonathan. I found the pressure setting for the full face mask to be too high when I changed to a nasal mask, but perhaps I should have persisted? I'll try again and I'll also discuss with the clinic whether an APAP…"
Mar 13
Jonathan replied to Frances Knight's discussion Air Sense 10 - changing pressure settings
"Ramble alert!  My history is that I spent part of each week at a different location, so bought a second machine identical to my fixed pressure NHS machine and set it up to match using the clinician menu.  This was a very long time…"
Mar 12
Frances Knight replied to Frances Knight's discussion Air Sense 10 - changing pressure settings
"Thanks Jonathan - I had seen the YouTube video. My question is really about the experience of people who have control of their pressure settings, for example those people who have bought their machines directly and not obtained them through an NHS…"
Mar 12
Jonathan replied to Frances Knight's discussion Air Sense 10 - changing pressure settings
"This is NOT a recommendation http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VNUWhd2UgQM"
Mar 11
Frances Knight posted a discussion

Air Sense 10 - changing pressure settings

I have been successfully using my air sense 10 since OSA diagnosis, and my AHI is now under 2. I had an appointment with my clinic this week and have been told there is no need for further appointments and just to contact them if I need supplies or…See More
Mar 11
Swen Greve is now a member of Hope2SleepGuide
Mar 4
Jonathan replied to Sue Reeves's discussion A few questions..
"If you have a helpful GP, I would ask them to re-refer you to the sleep clinic."
Mar 3
Sue Reeves posted a discussion

A few questions..

A quick bit of backgroundDiagnosed with OSA about 7/8 years ago by my local sleep clinic and given a F &P Icon CPAP.  After a couple of follow-up appts to sort out any issues, I was sent on my merry way. I have had no further face to face…See More
Mar 3
Jonathan replied to John's discussion Airsense 10 -humidifier runs dry
"I previously had a DeVilbiss Sleepcube and the dehumidifier did sometimes run dry.  On the other hand I now have an AirSense 10 and it never runs dry, and I've had the humidity turned up high."
Feb 26
John posted a discussion

Airsense 10 -humidifier runs dry

Hi. I'm finding the Airsense 10 the hospital gave me, the humidifier chamber runs dry. It's not even on max settings, which I'm guessing would empty it a lot quicker. Seems like a big design oversight to me. Does anyone else have this trouble? The…See More
Feb 26
David Hudson posted a discussion

Decline in hearing

HiI have regular, well yearly check ups at work. One being a hearing test. Since having my cpap machine my hearing has declined rapidly in 1 ear.....could this be as a result of pressure? I believe I'm on 15cm p max h2o. I just use a nasal…See More
Feb 26
Profile Icontim richards, mark & les, Lesley Parks and 1 more joined Hope2SleepGuide
Feb 13
Jenny Wren replied to Jenny Wren's discussion Feeling Abandoned by the Sleep Clinic
"I've got lucky! I can collect a new machine next week. It's been really helpful to 'speak' to people here and to Kath. It alerted me to the fact that I'd slipped through the net. The clinic were very apologetic and now all…"
Feb 8
Ejog1 replied to Jenny Wren's discussion Feeling Abandoned by the Sleep Clinic
"Thanks. Good news for me today, my clinic did finally reply to me and they’re giving me a new machine. The person I spoke to was super helpful. The NHS clinics are great when you’re able to speak to them, but they seem to be…"
Feb 7
Jenny Wren replied to Jenny Wren's discussion Feeling Abandoned by the Sleep Clinic
"Yes, my machine is affected. Seems I slipped through the net. I'm now on the sleep clinic's radar again and am hopeful that this will be sorted soon. Thanks for your reply and stay well."
Feb 7
Jenny Wren replied to Jenny Wren's discussion Feeling Abandoned by the Sleep Clinic
"I'm sorry to hear that. I emailed Kath about this and she was very helpful. She advised me to get in touch with my sleep clinic and I have had a reply from them. I so hope that you get a response soon."
Feb 7

© 2024   Created by The SleepGuide Crew.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service