Hope2SleepGuide

Sleep Apnoea Forum Bringing Help + Support to the Patient

DID THIS POOR LADY SUFFER FROM UNDIAGNOSED SLEEP APNOEA?

Just been reading this article on this rainy Bank Holiday Monday, and I can't help wondering if the poor lady had undiagnosed sleep apnoea, especially bearing in mind there was a history of it in the family.  Hindsight's a wonderful thing, but is too late for this lady.  I think all people who snore or are constantly tired and have other family members will sleep apnoea should be tested as a precaution.  As should pregnant women, although that's another subject for another discussion..........

 

A MUM died two weeks after starting a radical weight loss plan in the hope of having another baby, an inquest was told.

Joanne Shelbourne, 32, was found dead by her distraught husband, Kevin, at their family home.

A mum to three-year-old Adam, Joanne, who worked for Northern Rock at Doxford International, had been happily married for nearly six years.

An inquest yesterday was unable to determine what caused the unexpected death.

The hearing was told in the weeks leading up to her sudden death, Joanne, a size 18, had taken up a low-calorie diet for a second time, with the aim of losing weight in the hope of having another child.

Pathologist Dr Sidiq Tijani said that despite a post-mortem examination and numerous tests, he had been unable to confirm how Joanne had died.

Although the mum, who suffered from high blood pressure, was prescribed two different drugs, neither of them was found in her system.

There was also no evidence of alcohol or illegal drugs.

However, the hearing, at Doxford Park, was told there were traces of a chemical that the body often produces when it is starving.

Dr Tijani added there was a family history of sleep apnoea, a condition where sufferers have pauses in breathing while they sleep.

But Joanne’s family said she had not been diagnosed with the condition.

Dr Tijani added: “There is literature that states some individuals with pre-disposing conditions, as obesity and cigarette smoking and with a history of sleep apnoea, could die suddenly and no cause of death could be found.”

Coroner Derek Winter recorded a verdict of death by natural causes on the Washington mum, who died in February. The coroner found no link between Joanne’s diet and her sudden death.

Speaking after the inquest, Joanne’s grieving father, Michael Garrett, said: “We just can’t believe someone can die of natural causes aged 32.”

Joanne’s mum, Glenda Garrett, said she had been concerned that Joanne had adopted the low calorie Cambridge diet in the weeks prior to her death.

Eileen Skinner, managing director of the Cambridge Weight Plan, said: “We are saddened by the tragic death of Joanne and our sympathy goes out to her family.

“Each day many thousands of people safely use our programmes to lose weight. The coroner made no links whatsoever with any of the weight loss programmes available from Cambridge Weight Plan and the company was not invited to attend or even supply any information. It is important to note that the coroner’s verdict was ‘natural causes’.

“Obesity is a growing health problem. Medical opinion is clear that obesity can pose a significant risk to health, particularly for those with a higher BMI and we would urge anyone who is overweight to take action.”

Husband Kevin described his wife as a “beautiful person” and “brilliant mam”.

Verdict: natural causes.

 

http://bit.ly/khUhpG

Views: 449

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I am Joanne's husband and I would like to say that sleep apnoea had nothing to do with her death.

 

Thanks

Thanks for clarifying this Kevin.  My own mother died due to undiagnosed sleep apnoea, and I feared it was yet another case of this, which happens all too often.

I hope you and your family are gradually coming to terms with the sad loss of your wife - my heart goes out to you.

it took thirty years to diagnose my apnoea

people with apnoea find it very difficult to loses any weight, and it impacts a strain on other body parts including the heart

i am truly saddened by this story

Thank you for writing, Kevin.

What a terrible shock you and your family have endured. Please accept our condolences.



Kevin Shelbourne said:

I am Joanne's husband and I would like to say that sleep apnoea had nothing to do with her death.

 

Thanks

Reply to Discussion

RSS

About

Sleep Apnoea Forum

New to the Sleep Apnoea Forum? 

1. Stop by our Sleep Apnoea Welcome Center to introduce yourself to the SleepGuide community.
2. Start a New Topic of Conversation.
3. Post your photos - of yourself, your old CPAP machine, your new CPAP machine, your pet, something about you!

Interested in advertising, have a problem or need to contact us? Click the Report an Issue page.

 

Latest Activity

Jonathan replied to John's discussion Wellu O2 Ring - is it accurate enough for the medics?
"Hi The SleepCube was a private purchase, as way back then my local sleep clinic assessed patients by filming them overnight, whilst wearing an oximeter, and only issued CPAP machines without humidifiers.  There was no remote monitoring and…"
Oct 25
John replied to John's discussion Wellu O2 Ring - is it accurate enough for the medics?
"Yeah I was wondering about email address. I thought probably if they wanted me to mail them they would have given out an address. I can imagine heart data is considered more acute than sleep data, so it would make more sense to have that…"
Oct 24
Jonathan replied to John's discussion Wellu O2 Ring - is it accurate enough for the medics?
"Hi. I didn't use PatientsKnowBest (ironic name), but I have an email address for my heart department for sending in ECGs.  I was just saying that they may be able to review a PDF when then cannot review a data file from your O2 ring. I am…"
Oct 24
John replied to John's discussion Wellu O2 Ring - is it accurate enough for the medics?
"Hi Jonathan, did you do that through PatientKnowsBest?"
Oct 24
Jonathan replied to John's discussion Wellu O2 Ring - is it accurate enough for the medics?
"On an unrelated topic, I've been able to send ECGs by PDF to my heart clinic. On the subject of Resmed and apnoeas, take a look at https://youtu.be/ufOOAfyzZso?si=Tpdl4EEiCQBZR4iD&t=276 Your machine may be under-reporting. Good…"
Oct 24
John posted a discussion

Wellu O2 Ring - is it accurate enough for the medics?

Moving some furniture my long lost O2 ring continuous oxygen saturation monitor turned up. So I've been wearing it and it tells me I have loads of saturation drops during the night even though my Airsense 10 says I have very few apneas.So I get two…See More
Oct 21
Richard Smith replied to Richard Smith's discussion air bubbles after weight loss
"Hi, Just thought I'd give an update.  So, I had my appointment with the NHS sleep clinic which was much quicker than I anticipated and I've now had the overnight sleep study.  My AHI is now 6, down from over 30, so I'm…"
Oct 15
John replied to Sally Gray's discussion Microplastics risks
"Hi Sally from what I read the airsense doesn't suffer the same foam degredation issues as the infamous Phillips machine.I can conceive it's possible that microplastics may be shed from the flexible main tube.What worries me more about the…"
Oct 7
Jonathan replied to Richard Smith's discussion air bubbles after weight loss
"Hi My sleep clinic discharged me, saying they were happy I was self-managing.  Roll on a decade and the cardiologists taking care of me were very unimpressed and I was re-enrolled.  I expect remote monitoring with current generation Resmed…"
Sep 1
Richard Smith replied to Richard Smith's discussion air bubbles after weight loss
"Hi Jonathan, Thanks again for the info.  My cpap *should* be monitored by the NHS though I haven’t had any contact from them since pre-covid.  I checked out the link you gave to access extra data and I think that’s going to be…"
Aug 31
Jonathan replied to Richard Smith's discussion air bubbles after weight loss
"Hi I have the ResMed Airsense 10 Autoset (APAP).  It's monitored remotely by my NHS sleep clinic and I believe they can make changes to the settings.  I don't know whether they are notified if I make changes, nor whether they…"
Aug 31
Richard Smith replied to Richard Smith's discussion air bubbles after weight loss
"Hi Jonathan, Thanks for the reply.  I'd say that I'm fairly technical.  I have the ResMed Airsense 10 Elite machine.  I've discovered that I can upload data wirelessly from my machine and having lowered the pressure by…"
Aug 30
Jonathan replied to Richard Smith's discussion air bubbles after weight loss
"Hi You don't say how technical you are, or what sort of machine you use.  However https://www.sleephq.com/ has software which allows you to upload data from compatible machines, and analyse your sleep "score", including a…"
Aug 29
Richard Smith posted a discussion

air bubbles after weight loss

Hi,I've been on Mounjaro for about 3 months now, not primarily for weight loss, but I have lost weight around my face and neck.  I've noticed that I am increasingly getting air bubbles in my mouth which of course is disturbing my sleep (and my…See More
Aug 28
Sally Gray posted a discussion

Micro plastics risks

I was reading an article in the I newspaper today written by a journalist who had her blood tested for micro plastics and was shocked by the results.…See More
Aug 3
Alison Mitchell is now a member of Hope2SleepGuide
Jul 2
John posted a discussion

job with the charity

Was wondering if there might be a job for me with Hope2Sleep?(I also just asked this of a group by mistake)See More
Jun 27
Tracey Tilley updated their profile
May 22
Sharon Sullivan posted a discussion

For Sale - Ventura Full Total Face CPAP Mask

I’m selling an Ventura Full Total Face CPAP Mask Large and two spare liners.  I bought it new from the Hope2Sleep shop, but it is not suitable for me.  Only used for about two weeks so I have washed it thoroughly.   Because of this, it is very much…See More
May 17
Tracey Tilley replied to Jim Scullion's discussion UK Attendance Allowance
"I put in a claim for PIP which was denied and now I am over 66 and on pension I tried for AA. Denied again.I have other health conditions ( Diverticular disease and Bile Acid Malabsorbtion ) which I consider hard to live with and they refused all of…"
May 14

© 2025   Created by The SleepGuide Crew.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service